Dead man’s consent not necessary for sperm donation


19 January 2007

Victory in dead Israeli sperm row

The lawyer of an Israeli couple who won the right to use their dead son’s sperm to inseminate a woman he never met says the case is a boost for family rights.

I don’t see why this is a boost for family rights. It’s taken more rights from men away, at least in Israel (although there was a similar case in the UK a while ago whereby a widow, Diane Blood, was able to given permission to conceive two children using pre-fertilized embryos her and her late husband had had frozen.)

Irit Rosenblum told the BBC the landmark ruling meant family lines could continue even without the written consent of the male prior to death.

Fucking hell. So even in death, it seems, us men are fair game to be harvested for sperm then?

I can understand the guy’s parents wanting grandchildren, but I think it’s still wrong. Do they not consider the feelings of the child that will result from this? Fancy not only being raised without a father, but being born five-years after he died, not to mention knowing your mum and dad never even met. Or that your dad never gave express consent for you to be created.

That kid will probably spend a lot of their adolescence on a psychiatrist’s couch.

posted by Duncan Idaho @ 6:56 PM


At 7:12 PM, Viking said…

If you want grandchildren badly or if you simply want to continue your family line, have more than one or two children in the first damn place and raise them to love family life and children.

This is the price of generational selfishness.


At 8:48 PM, Anonymous said…

Well atleast he won’t have to pay support, then again, maybe it’s a way to garnish the life insurance. You just never know, and it surely opens another door. So much for cloning, this is the real deal!


At 12:32 AM, Anonymous said…

I don’t know guys are interested but I wrote a piece called Fuckers and Suckers which I have posted on the Do Not Get Married Message Board.

After reading the nomarriage ebook, the author talks about two groups of men fuckers and suckers.

Keep in mind western women love excitement and hate boredom. When they are in their teens and early 20’s they don’t want stability that suckers have to offer because that is boring.

Keep in mind that women don’t think for themselves but decisions on who they date or sleep with is usually made by the council not by the woman herself. This council is usually made up of her mother, sister, and friends etc. If dating a nice guy is not considered to be fun and popular by the “council” he is going to get snubbed.

There is another group of guys called fuckers. Women love to have sex with these guys during their prime years. Although they offer no stability to these women, however women will still sleep with them. The reason why women will is because they are unpredictable and therefore they are deemed as very exciting.

Once these women get to there late 20’s – early 30’s they will fraudulently sell their looks to suckers who make a good income in order to get married. In other words they will put on a pony show for them until they get the ring. After a few years of marriage, these women are going to get bored and everything is the suckers fault. They will look for affairs and cash out on their suckers knowing that they will get the house, child support (if they have children), and alimony. All she has to do is file a false abuse charge (no proof necessary) to make all this happen. Even as a bonus, the sucker even gets to pay for her attorney fees.

Also, remember guys a women’s fertility starts to decline at age 27 not in her 30’s and 40’s. If any of you want to start a family I highly recommend to make sure that the woman you are going to start a family with is no older than 25.

Despite their not being any legal justice in this country, Mother Nature has a justice of her own.

Those suckers who once ached for these women will lose interest in them once they get to be in their mid to late 20’s. The last thing they are going to find attractive are used up women in their late 20’s-30’s. In fact these women must be avoided at all cost. They got a disease called baby rabies. They are going to do everything possible to get pregnant and trap you into a long term relationship where they can get provided for.

However, once those “suckers” get financially stable they will get to travel to foreign countries and enjoy beautiful women. Also, while in the United States, they will have developed fun hobbies to do when they are not working. In fact these “suckers” will not have to deal with the stress of fear of divorce, a nagging whore, false abuse and rape chargers, get to keep their sanity and money, won’t have to worry about raising kid that aren’t theirs etc.

However, the women who neglected the “suckers” in favor of the “fuckers” during their prime years are going to have to face justice. It’s not legal justice but Mother Nature justice. Once they get to their late 20’s for every year a man ages, they will be aging by two years. They will wrinkle and get ugly very fast. Investing thousands of dollars in makeup in order to form a bond with a “sucker” is not going to get the job done because they failed to form a bond with a “sucker” during their prime years. Their biological clocks will be ticking and they will get very desperate. They are going to want to be talking care off, like living off a “sucker” so they won’t have to work. Disgusted by their behavior, the “suckers” will not want anything to do with them and will rebuke them. They are going to have to work long hours for the rest of their life because they could not find a “sucker” to take care of them. They will whine and complain that the “suckers” will not commit despite them snubbing them in favor of the “fuckers” during their prime years. They will rot all alone with no one to take care of them, many of them will not get to have children, and will be living very miserable lives until death all because they thought it was cute to let the “suckers” rot all alone while they go squander their prime years to the “fuckers” That my friends is what I call justice!

– Outcast Superstar


At 1:36 AM, FredXblog said…

Good piece Duncan

I agree- this will have psychological consequences for the poor kid

This is actually quite a tragic story; for both the dead man and the child he never consented to having, nor perhaps even wanted


At 3:02 PM, Javier said…

I hope the child(ren) born from this “I want so I get” shit grow up and realize what a bunch of fucking selfish shits they had for grandparents and sue the hell out of them because their rights as a sperm were denied to exist the way they wanted. Wouldn’t that be some shit? This madness appears to have no end.


%d bloggers like this: